How to Choose the Right Cabinet Company
How to Choose the Right Cabinet Company for Your Kitchen, Bathroom, or Whole Home Remodel
Remodeling your kitchen, bathroom, or entire home is an exciting opportunity to elevate your lifestyle—and the cabinetry you choose plays a defining role in both function and aesthetic. At Magnolia Cabinet Co., we’ve helped discerning homeowners across Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, and the barrier islands navigate this very decision.
With so many cabinet providers to choose from—ranging from big-box retailers to boutique custom shops—how do you know which one will bring your vision to life with integrity, craftsmanship, and attention to detail? Here’s our expert guide to selecting the right cabinet company for your Southwest Florida remodel.
1. Define Your Project Scope, Style, and Budget
Before comparing companies, take time to clarify your priorities:
Are you renovating a single space or your entire home?
Do you want fully custom cabinetry, semi-custom solutions, or something more standard?
What design styles inspire you—classic coastal, modern minimalism, or transitional luxury?
What’s your realistic budget range?
Cabinetry typically accounts for 40–50% of a kitchen remodel. Having a clear vision will help you identify companies with the right offerings—and save time and stress in the selection process.
2. Research Cabinet Makers Who Understand Your Market
Experience Matters—Especially in High-End Sarasota Homes
Not all cabinet companies operate at the same level. Look for partners with a track record in custom homes and luxury renovations, especially in established communities like The Lake Club, The Oaks, Bird Key, or Longboat Key.
When evaluating providers, check:
Reputation: Verified reviews on Google, Houzz, and local directories
Portfolio: Recent projects in homes like yours—style, size, and scope
Experience: How long have they been in business, and do they work with builders or designers?
Specialization: Do they offer both design and installation under one roof?
At Magnolia, we’ve been transforming homes in Sarasota since 2015, often collaborating directly with local builders and interior designers to ensure a seamless, stress-free process.
3. Evaluate Materials and Craftsmanship
The Details Make the Difference
Cabinetry is one of the longest-lasting elements of your remodel—so quality construction is key. Ask these questions when evaluating a company’s product:
Are the cabinets built from premium solid hardwoods or durable plywood?
Do they use dovetail joinery, soft-close hinges, and full-extension slides as standard?
Is the finish hand-applied, catalyzed, or UV-cured for longevity and beauty?
Do they stand behind their work with a strong warranty?
At Magnolia, our cabinetry is 100% made in America and handcrafted by skilled artisans using time-honored techniques and the finest materials. Every piece is built to last—not just until the next trend cycle, but for generations.
4. Visit the Showroom to See the Difference
Experience Magnolia’s Craftsmanship in the Heart of Sarasota
There’s no substitute for seeing exceptional cabinetry in person—and that’s exactly what our Sarasota showroom is designed for. Located just minutes from downtown on Osprey Avenue, our curated space showcases the quality, versatility, and beauty that set Magnolia Cabinet Co. apart.
Step inside and you’ll find:
Full-scale custom kitchen and bathroom displays with integrated lighting
Modern and transitional design vignettes featuring premium wood finishes and luxury hardware
Innovative cabinetry features like under-cabinet LED strips, hidden storage, and built-in bar lighting
Experienced designers on-site to answer your questions and help you visualize your space
Whether you're building a new home in The Lake Club or planning a renovation on Bird Key, visiting our showroom is the best way to explore our work—and get inspired by what’s possible.
Step inside our Sarasota showroom to experience fully custom cabinetry in person—like this sleek walnut kitchen display with integrated lighting and modern design touches.
5. Meet the Team Behind the Experience
Local Experts Committed to Craftsmanship and Care
At Magnolia Cabinet Co., exceptional cabinetry is only part of the story. What truly sets us apart is the team of professionals who guide you through every phase of your project—from initial design to final installation. Sarasota homeowners and builders alike trust us not just for the quality of our work, but for the integrity and care we bring to the entire process.
Meet a few of the people who make it all happen:
Melvin Stoltzfus – General Manager
Leads with decades of experience and an unwavering commitment to quality.
Carol Care – Finance Manager
Keeps your project on budget and running smoothly behind the scenes.
Mark King – Sales Manager
Helps match each client with the ideal cabinetry solution for their vision and home.
Dylan Heinz – Logistics Manager
Ensures timely, careful delivery and coordination from our workshop to your door.
Jessica Haughton & Louise Beckwith – Client Liaisons
Your personal guides throughout the process—always just a phone call or showroom visit away.
At Magnolia, customer service isn’t a department—it’s the heart of our business. Whether you’re remodeling a kitchen in Laurel Oak or designing a custom closet on Siesta Key, you can expect a team that’s efficient, friendly, and fully invested in your satisfaction.
6. Consider Overall Value—Not Just the Price Tag
What’s Included Matters Just as Much as the Bottom Line
Custom cabinetry isn’t inexpensive—but not all “custom” work is created equal. Look beyond price and ask:
Does the quote include installation and finishing?
Are lighting, organizational features, or accessories part of the package?
What kind of support is available after installation?
We often help clients compare quotes that, on the surface, seem similar—but only one includes handmade joinery, integrated lighting, and personalized service from start to finish.
7. Seek Trusted Referrals
Local Experience You Can Verify
Word of mouth is invaluable in a close-knit community like Sarasota. Ask friends, neighbors, or your builder for recommendations. Or ask the cabinet company for references from recent clients.
At Magnolia, many of our clients come from referrals—and we’re always proud to let our work speak for itself.
8. Go With the Company That Feels Right
The Right Fit Is About Trust
Beyond features and pricing, trust your instincts. A great cabinet company will make you feel heard, respected, and confident about the road ahead. If something feels off—whether it’s unclear communication or lackluster service—keep looking.
Your cabinetry will define how your home looks, feels, and functions for years to come. Choose a partner who honors that responsibility.
Why Magnolia Cabinet Co.?
✔ Trusted in Sarasota since 2015
✔ 100% made in America, handcrafted by artisan craftsmen
✔ Custom and semi-custom cabinetry for every space in your home
✔ In-house designers and expert installers
✔ Seamless process from consultation to final reveal
✔ Deep experience working with homeowners, builders, and designers across Southwest Florida
Whether you’re remodeling a kitchen in The Lake Club, upgrading a bathroom in Laurel Oak, or designing your dream home on Siesta Key, Magnolia Cabinet Co. delivers craftsmanship, care, and cabinetry you’ll admire for a lifetime.
Schedule Your Design Consultation Today
Visit us at 1830 S Osprey Ave, Suite 107, Sarasota FL
Call today at 941-906-8744